Rubric

Find Rubric
Article Review Rubric (1)
Article Review Rubric (1)
Criteria Ratings Pts
Summary of Content and Context
threshold: pts
50 pts
Proficient
Provides a thorough , clear and concise summary of the article context and content
35 pts
Competent
Provides a clear but shallow summary of the article; may be excessively brief or may include some extraneous information.
15 pts
Novice
Provides a somewhat muddled, unclear and rambling summary of the article.
0 pts
Unacceptable
Provides an unclear and unintelligible summary of the article OR No summary at all.
pts
50 pts
--
Identify, Describe, Personal Reaction
threshold: pts
35 pts
Proficient
Thoroughly describes your personal reaction to and how you will use what you have learned from the article; includes discussion of the relevant issues within the article.
24.5 pts
Competent
Describes your personal reaction to and how you will use what you have learned from the article; includes no discussion of the relevant issues within the article
10.5 pts
Novice
Attempts to describe your personal reaction to how you will use what you have learned from the article, but lacks a logical flow and reaction is muddled; no discussion of any relevant issues in the article.
0 pts
Unacceptable
Illogical description of personal reaction OR No description of personal reaction at all
pts
35 pts
--
Grammar, Spelling, APA
threshold: pts
15 pts
Proficient
Contains all correct information regarding article title, author name, and article source and date. Consistently contains accurate and proper grammatical conventions, spelling, and punctuation. Clearly and consistently uses proper APA formatting
10.5 pts
Competent
Contains mostly correct info regarding article title, author name, and article source and date. Contains frequent errors in grammatical conventions, spelling, and punctuation; errors begin to interfere with paper’s meaning. Inconsistently uses APA
4.5 pts
Novice
Contains incorrect info regarding article title, author name, and article source and date. Contains numerous errors in grammatical conventions, spelling, and punctuation; substantially interferes with paper’s meaning
0 pts
Unacceptable
Response is totally unintelligible OR No response
pts
15 pts
--
Total Points: 100 out of 100